Monday, November 16, 2015

Importance of Reflection in Design Thinking Learning


One of the big benefits that we have seen by integrating design thinking into our curriculum is the way in which it breaks down the thinking, creating, reflecting, refining and sharing process. As you know from prior posts, we designed our own Parker Design Thinking process. We spent a large part of our year last year ingraining this with our faculty and students. This year our focus has been to bring this process to life as we work with students to tackle integrated design thinking projects.

One of the major components of this is reflection. Theorists from Piaget to Vygotsky to Bandura have all advocated the benefits of metacognitive strategy use with students of all ages. The more students reflect on their learning and the process of learning, the more they build confidence in their capability to achieve realistic goals in subsequent projects. This is commonly known as the self-regulatory, self-efficacy cycle. When students can self-regulate (e.g., they know how to monitor their progress and adjust goals and deadlines) they become more confident in their ability which leads to increased self-efficacy (e.g., they know they can do it). Additional benefits of being able to capably manage time and articulate needed steps also arise from using structured reflection.

We are using reflection in a variety of ways within the Scripps Design Center and in our design thinking project. Sometimes it is written, sometimes it is full group, sometimes it is individual, sometimes it happens in small groups. Sometimes we orient on a specific skill or problem, while other times we speak to more generalized issues that are presenting themselves. We try very hard to adapt to the situation and where our students are in their work.

This year we are intentionally focusing kids on reflecting on their process and skill development in addition to content learning. We've tackled this in a few ways. One way we have done this is to use our design thinking process to help kids with reflecting. Below you see some great examples of how we formalized the reflection component following the completion of a project. Students articulated their work using the steps.

Each step of the Parker Design Process is articulated vis-a-vis a specific project by students. 

We often use this reflection as a way to evaluate what students got out of the day's lesson as well as to help us determine where we need to go with subsequent sessions - in other words, this has become a powerful formative assessment cycle for both kids and faculty.

A huge HUGE win is that while we (faculty) guided these reflection sessions initially, students are now leading the charge. In the photo below, you see a student up front guiding her peers through a reflection on a lesson in which they had built squishy circuits. We are now seeing classroom teachers tapping this student skill in the general classrooms as well, which is very awesome to see.

A student leads her peers in reflecting on what was accomplished in class, as well as talking about next steps. 

Monday, November 9, 2015

5th Grade Project: Survivor Project

Survivor project: we did this project last year (see earlier blog post near the start of this blog).

Survival project is five years old, and it started as a PBL activity. Empathy is the biggest change in this project and as we have reworked it we have moved more towards getting kids to really live and understand the challenges inherent in early peoples. Kids have appreciation and understanding of early peoples, and that's what we really wanted them to get. Cooperation v conflict piece. Having them do things in authentic ways where learning is real. Tying in common threads all the way through curriculum to the design center. Tie ins to the books they read, etc.

Students build shelters and basic hunting weapons as part of this unit of study. The biggest difference from last year is that we did a two day build on shelters instead of just one day. This way students could plan it out more and also see if their shelters could stand up overnight. Making fire was not a part of the build this time around. We added in making water vessels and spear making/throwing (tool making) this year as it was a better use of time and also more student-friendly (could be tested indoors or outdoors). Materials for structures were more standardized to be more even for all teams.

This time around we had students do open ended research and then use their social studies book to get more specific info about their region. We also had a parent come in this year to talk with students - they are a survivalist, teaches Marines on survival techniques, and it was intense. Kids learned a lot from him and they enjoyed that lesson immensely.

Bottom line? Kids love this project! They made spears and got to throw them at a box. The tool making was the best part of this for the kids. Better appreciation for the fact that it is difficult to make things and live with primitive tools. They see how hard it is to "hunt" so they end up realizing berry picking. Of 60 kids only 4 had successful spear building (spear stuck in the box). The difficulties of making work-able solutions with basic materials was a BIG realization for kids. Great learning!

Reflection:
Next year - start bringing in materials at the start of school so that we have enough materials for all teams. We need to make a stronger curriculum tie in: how does geography and climate affect culture and housing for people. They are learning about different regions, etc.